Multithreading and more…

So since the very inception of Zombox, I’ve always been fighting with Unity, trying to get it to pump out as many polygons as possible without getting too many slowdowns on mobile devices. Zombox features a huge open world, so this has always been a massive challenge.

When I first started working on the game, I made sure everything was super low poly. Then I learned that Unity can batch geometry to the GPU if it’s low-poly and shares the same material — so I made sure all the geometry in the city used only one material with a large texture atlas. Then when that wasn’t enough, I simplified the geometry on everything further. After that, I developed a seamless world-culling system so that the only geometry that would ever be loaded is what would be on-screen at the time. Even then, I was always treading a very fine line with regards to performance. I had to be very careful not to group too many objects together in the city or draw calls would get too high and the game would chug.

In December I described my custom batching solution to the draw call problem. However, while my batching system greatly reduced draw calls, it created another problem that was still lingering: the batching system itself has a pretty high CPU overhead. It’s not high enough to negate its positive effect on overall performance, but it’s still high enough to be a pretty serious problem. After all, nobody wants to experience annoying framerate hits every few seconds as they walk around the game world.

This week I realized that basically all mobile devices I’m targeting have at least 2 cores in their main CPU (iPhone 4S and above). So with that in mind, I decided to try multithreading the batching system I developed. One of the downsides of Unity is that you cannot access any UnityEngine classes from secondary threads (thereby making multithreading for all built-in Unity objects impossible). But, one of the upsides of my new batching system is that it doesn’t actually rely on any UnityEngine classes! So with that in mind, I was able to quickly and easily shift all mesh calculations (besides those that actually assign the final vert/uv/color/triangles sets to the Unity Mesh objects) to a second thread.

And voila! This idea turned out to work almost like magic! I can now pump *tons* of geometry at my batching system with almost no impact on the core thread of the game — meaning that no matter how complicated the city’s geometry is (within reason), it will never cause the game to stutter or slow down. The game actually runs faster now, with *twice* the amount of on-screen geometry, than it did before with half that geometry!

So this has allowed me to add some stuff to the game that I’ve been wanting to add for years, but never knew how I could do it without killing performance — namely, grass, twigs, stones, debris, and all sorts of other ground details! For years the game has consisted of nothing more than buildings and props on top of completely flat textured planes. There were a few minor ground details scattered throughout, but they were very limited in their distribution to keep them from lagging the game. But not anymore! Check out this before/after animation and take note of all the extra ground detail:

All of this is now easily possible, without any impact on the game’s overall performance! It has been an exciting week for sure.

Now, multithreading my batching system was only one half of what was accomplished this last week. The other half was figuring out a simple, memory-efficient way of being able to quickly identify what type of substance each point of the city’s ground surface consists of. In order to add grass, and other details throughout the world, I need to know where those details should go. After all, we don’t want grass growing inside houses or on the road, for example.

My solution was to define a grid in 3d space, in 3d studio max, that uses material IDs to specify different types of ground substances. The grid system is resolution-independent so that some ground tiles can have less dense grids than others (after all, we don’t need hundreds of grid cells to tell us that the middle of the ocean is composed of water, but we might need hundreds of cells to differentiate between grass patches, mud patches, concrete patches and other substances within the city). This grid is then exported from 3dsmax into a pre-built C# file that auto-loads this substance information into Zombox without any extra computations/loading required. The result is very fast grid->substance lookups that give the game quick access to all the information it needs about what is under the player’s fee, with very little memory overhead.

And the added benefit of this system is that being able to identify ground substances means I can allow the player to do things like…dig! We wouldn’t want the player to be able to dig dirt out of the sidewalk or the road…but if we can find out that the player is standing on some dirt…well, it would make sense to allow for some digging there! This substance lookup system is perfect for that. As you can see, when the player steps onto dirt, the shovel icon appears and he can dig for dirt/clay, which can then be used in various crafting recipes. The substance information is also useful for other purposes as well….it’s an easy way for me to perform checks that prevent players from being able to craft over water, or it allows me to do things like add particle effects for when the player is running through tall grass, etc. Eventually it might lead to the inclusion of other easter eggs…like the ability to dig up treasure?….We’ll see!

Here’s an animation of the player digging up dirt items, which can later be collected and used for crafting:

Apologies for the long post, hopefully some people find it informative!



27 Responses to “Multithreading and more…”

  1. Slhoth says:

    Awesome stuff.
    It looks heaps better with the extra ground geometry.

  2. Spracky says:

    Another update?! Loving it!

  3. Valentin says:

    I found it informative, Thanks!! :D

  4. GetaVe says:

    Wow man, you are killing it with these updates! Great stuff!

  5. Rudi says:

    It really is heart-warming to see that you are making progress on Zombox! Great work, man!

  6. Anonymous says:

    If it’s only going to be on iOS devices, i’m totally going to switch haha! this game is freaking amazing looking! been following it since 2012!! it’s coming along really nice now Tyson, and these updates are very very very appreciated. Also, this long update was actually really entertaining to read! :D

  7. Ricky says:

    Great work on your progress! Can’t wait to play this.

    Is this gonna be on Android as well btw?

  8. Jason says:

    Awesome !!
    I mean I can make games myself, but the optimization you are doing is stunning.
    Is there any chance that you’ll release the code for those performance related issues ?

  9. Tynon mercer says:

    Dude ive been waiting and still am loving your updates and im glad that you dont rush and realese it like one month after you had announced it but im loving your other games too and im sure thos one will be a killer game

  10. Spracky says:

    Almost a month with no updates ;(

  11. Moises Alvarado says:

    Hey! These updates look great man! Don’t know how long I’ve been following this website but props to you man! You’ve been through a ton to make as much progress as you have! Keep it up can’t wait.

  12. rene0121 says:

    Wooo glad to have seen This update. It’s been a hile since I last checked up on this glad to see so much progress two months before this post. Hope you’ll finish before 2016 although I’m all for waiting to obtain a quality game

  13. Tirarex says:

    Tools for texturing and modeling ? Please tell to !!!

  14. jormaje says:

    This project is awesome. Great job :D

  15. Steve says:

    Are you planning some beat testing in future?
    I would like to be one of the testers :)

  16. Flanua says:

    This game looks awesome! And main character is very hilarious. :)
    This game will be the best open world game on iOS.

  17. Anonymous says:

    Looks awesome Tyson! Great work and I would pay 5$ or possibly more for this amazing iOS game! If you put it on steam you should charge 10-30 dollars though! Love your work ;) hope it comes out soon.

  18. Ahmed says:

    Awesome man!! just release the game :D

    On the other hand I’d really love to see an article explaining in detail on how to utilize multiple cores of mobile devices. I also develop games in unity3d and the only optimizations I go for are batching, combined meshes, loading map parts in chunk and using atlas textures..

    Keep up the good work :)

  19. Jimmay says:

    been 7 months since an update. Whats up?

  20. ryan says:

    Maybe he died a long ago. This project were very promising. But now it is slowly going into the shadow. It’s pity.

Log in or Register

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>